She won a religious exemption from using AI at work

A Software Engineer Won a Religious Exemption From Using AI at Work - Business Insider

Pope Leo XIV, who warned last month that AI could undermine human dignity and displace workers if left unchecked.

TIZIANA FABI/AFP via Getty Images

2026-06-05T09:40:01.230Z

Read in app

Save Saved

This story is available exclusively to Business Insider subscribers. Become an Insider and start reading now. Have an account? .

"I'm writing my code and reviewing my code by hand, which seems crazy to say," said the 34-year-old, who lives in North Carolina and works for a large tech-entertainment company that she described as progressive. "Just two years ago, how else would you do it?"

Maus' AI workaround comes as a growing number of employers mandate and track workers' AI usage. The technology has also recently drawn scrutiny from Pope Leo XIV, who warned last month that AI could undermine human dignity and displace workers if left unchecked, in a more than 42,000-word encyclical.

Some people have interpreted the pontiff's letter as grounds for religious objections to using AI in the workplace. It's a stance that carries real legal weight, given that federal law requires employers to consider faith-based requests.

"The funniest possible outcome of the AI mandate era is about to be HR departments discovering that 'sincerely held religious belief' under Title VII has a much lower bar than they assumed, and Pope Leo handed every Catholic employee a written excuse," wrote Corey Quinn, a software-startup founder in San Francisco, on X.

Discover Level Up

Take smart steps toward the goals you've been thinking about.

Try it now

Explore BI Games

Take a smarter break in your day - and see how far you get.

Play now

'Playing priest'

Unitarian Universalists recognize that advances in technology must be guided by an ethical understanding of humanity, said Suzanne Morse, a spokeswoman for the Unitarian Universalist Association. The group is currently developing a policy about the use of AI and a theological statement on it, she said.

As more religious groups wrestle with AI's ethical implications, some employment lawyers see a potential workplace conundrum. While discussions about faith-based objections to the technology were underway before Pope Leo released his encyclical on Memorial Day, they say that his intervention could spur a new wave of workers to seek faith-based exemptions from AI requirements.

Employers "might have to promulgate some rules about this very quickly," said John J. Meehan, an attorney who specializes in workplace discrimination and labor law with law firm Joseph & Norinsberg. "If I were one of the bigger defense-side employment firms, I'd be doing that right now."

Workers filed more than 3,600 religion-based discrimination charges with the US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission in fiscal 2024, about 70% more than in 2021, the last full fiscal year before vaccine-mandate disputes drove a sharp increase in filings.

Employers could wind up in court if they outright dismiss workers who request a faith-based exemption from using AI, said Ashley Herd, a former McKinsey counsel and head of North American HR who now advises managers and employers on workplace issues.

"Playing priest, and telling employees their request isn't legitimate, does not tend to bode well for companies," said Herd, also a cohost of the "HR Besties" podcast. "A jury doesn't like it when employees get made fun of by managers or HR."

In 2023, the Supreme Court ruled in favor of a postal worker who sought an exemption from Sunday shifts for religious reasons. The decision raised the bar for employers seeking to deny religious accommodations, making it harder to reject requests on the grounds that they create workplace burdens.

Even so, Pope Leo's remarks may not be a Hail Mary for workers looking to dodge AI. Dr. Michael Naughton, director of the Center for Catholic Studies at the University of St. Thomas, said the pontiff didn't imply that Catholic workers shouldn't adopt AI, but rather questioned whether it advances or diminishes human agency.

"It's probably going down the wrong alley to say this is a religious right, that 'I don't have to use it' " in the workplace, Naughton said.

A case for opting out

Workplace concerns are only one manifestation of a broader backlash against AI. At some college graduation ceremonies this spring, students heckled commencement speakers who praised the technology, while residents nationwide are fighting the construction of AI data centers.

Nearly a third of workers harbor negative feelings — including anxiety, uncertainty, and resistance — toward AI, according to a May study from HR software company Cornerstone. The findings are based on a survey of 2,000 US and UK workers by research firm Censuswide.

Carina Cortez, chief people officer at Cornerstone, said she's seen workers resist new technology in the past and eventually come to embrace it. Though Cornerstone doesn't require its roughly 3,500 employees to use AI, she warned that people who dismiss it for any reason could dent their careers, as the technology is becoming ubiquitous in the workplace.

"Opting out today can mean falling behind tomorrow," Cortez said.

For now, Maus isn't worried about being left behind. She said she recently completed a coding task at the same speed as a colleague who used AI to handle a nearly identical assignment.

"AI doesn't really seem to be this game changer," she said, adding that her experience with the technology has only reinforced her view. "Your principles matter."

AI

Religion

HOME

Subscribe

This story is available exclusively to Business Insider subscribers. Become an Insider and start reading now. Have an account? .

Jump to

Main content

Search

Account

Jump to top of page

Every time publishes a story, you’ll get an alert straight to your inbox!

Look out for an alert in your inbox the next time publishes a story!

Every time a new story is published, you’ll get an alert straight to your inbox!

Look out for an alert in your inbox the next time a new story is published!

Enter your email

By clicking “Sign up”, you agree to receive emails from Business Insider. In addition, you accept Insider’s Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

More stories by More stories from